Lately I've been sitting with something that didn't used to bother me: how easy it is now to have an idea.
Open a chat window, describe a half-formed thought, and within seconds you have ten directions to take it, a structure, counterarguments, even a name for it. The friction that used to sit between "I have a notion" and "I have something I could actually build" has mostly dissolved. That should feel like abundance. Most days it doesn't. It feels like standing at the start of a race where everyone else has already heard the gun.
There's an Oromo folktale that I think explains this better than anything I could come up with on my own, so I'll tell it the way I remember being told it.
Three men, none of them with much to their name, are walking together looking for work. They stop to rest under a tree. To pass the time, they start daydreaming out loud about getting rich. One of them looks at the soft dirt under the tree and says, half-joking, "Imagine if we dug right here and found a huge clay pot stuffed with gold and silver."
That should have been the end of it. Instead, the second man's eyes light up. "If we found it," he says, "we'd split it three ways. My share goes straight to cattle — enough to make me the most respected man in the region." The third man doesn't like that at all. "Unfair. Your cattle will overrun everyone's land. If we find this treasure, we divide it right here, and I'm keeping mine as cash, to build an estate." Before either of them can answer, the first man jumps in: "Wait — I'm the one who thought of the spot. I noticed it first. I deserve the bigger half, and you two can split what's left."
Within a minute they're not negotiating anymore, they're furious. The second man threatens to let his imaginary cattle trample the third man's imaginary estate. The third man grabs a stick and swears he'll kill those same cattle the moment they wander near his land. The first man wades in to defend his claim to the biggest share. It turns into a real fight — fists, scratching, a stick coming down — and it doesn't stop until all three of them are bruised, bleeding, and lying in the dirt they'd been arguing over, too exhausted to get back up.
That's when an elder happens by on his mule. He sees three grown men flattened in the dirt and asks what bandits did this to them. Gasping, the first man points at his friends: "They tried to rob me of my share of the gold." The second one shouts back that the first man was trying to take more than his third. The elder looks around, genuinely confused, and asks the obvious question: where is this gold, exactly?
They look down. The ground under the tree is untouched. Nobody had picked up a shovel. There was no pot, no gold, nothing — just three men who had nearly killed each other defending shares of a treasure none of them had lifted a finger to find. The elder's line is the whole story in one sentence: "You are fools who bleed for shadows. You have broken your bones over wealth that does not exist, destroying your friendship for a lie."
I don't think that story is really about money, or even about greed exactly. I think it's about what happens when imagining something starts to feel the same as finding it. The three men never touched a shovel, but by the time the fight breaks out, the treasure is already real to them — real enough to defend, divide, and nearly die over. That's the part that transfers. Nobody has to be fighting another person for this to happen. All it takes is enough uninterrupted daydreaming for an idea to start feeling settled before anything has actually tested whether it's there.
That's exactly what a chat window does to an idea now. It's not that anyone's fighting over who gets to claim it — most of the time there's no one else in the room. It's that the daydreaming itself has gotten frictionless and tireless in a way it never used to be. You used to run out of a daydream. You'd think something through, hit the limits of what you could reason out alone, and either go find out if it held up or let it go. Now the chat window just keeps going — another angle, another structure, another reason it might work — and there's no natural point where the speculating has to stop and the finding-out has to start. The three men under the tree eventually got tired of imagining and turned to fighting instead. We don't even get that forcing function anymore. We can keep dreaming, politely, indefinitely, with something that never gets tired, never gets impatient, and never once tells us to go check.
The cost of that isn't competition with anyone else. It's accumulation. Every idea that stays in the daydreaming stage is an open loop, and open loops don't sit quietly. They don't announce themselves as unfinished the way an abandoned project does — they just sit there half-real, feeling more solved than they actually are, waiting on a step that never quite feels urgent enough to take. A handful of those is fine. A backlog of them is what actually wears a person down: not racing anyone, just carrying around a growing number of things that feel almost real and have never once been tested against anything outside your own head.
I don't think the fix is to stop daydreaming, and it's definitely not to distrust every idea a chat window helps you reach. The fix is the thing the elder in the story never quite had to say out loud, because the three men learned it the hard way: a thought doesn't become real just because it's been imagined clearly and defended confidently. It becomes real when something outside your own head gets to react to it. Publishing is the first dig. Posting something where someone else can actually read it, disagree with it, or build on it is the moment an idea stops being a story you're telling yourself and starts being something that either holds up or doesn't.
That's most of why this site exists in the shape it does. Not to help anyone generate more ideas — the chat window already does that, endlessly, for free — but to shrink the distance between having one and finding out, fast, whether there's actually anything there: a published piece, a finished manuscript, eventually a filed patent. Every one of those is a shovel going into the ground. None of them guarantee you hit gold. But at least you'll know.
Speed of imagining was never the hard part, and it was never something worth trying to control — a chat window can throw out more angles, faster, than any of us could alone, for as long as we keep asking. The only part worth getting good at is the part right after: actually digging, instead of staying comfortable under the tree.
The elder in that story never tells the three men to stop dreaming about treasure. He just points out, as gently as you can after watching someone get beaten half to death over nothing, that dreaming isn't the same as finding, and defending a dream like it's already dug up is how you end up with nothing but bruises and a broken friendship to show for it. I'd rather dig.
Comments
0 comments
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment on this post.
Sign InNo comments yet. Start the conversation.